Doug Rosenberg’s Transcriptions #2: John Coltrane solo on “Someday My Prince Will Come”

MDSDMPWC

For the second solo in this series, I have published the sheet music to John Coltrane’s solo from “Someday My Prince Will Come” [SMPWC]. This is a musical situation where you can hear the tumult of the 60’s impose itself on the very last remnants of Eisenhower’s 50’s. The whole album, a Miles Davis classic, is generally subdued, a 5-star classic. Despite its neo-conservatism, it deserves all its popularity for the excellence of playing. It’s swinging, beautiful, sonorous, despite being stylistically regressive. Within the next ten years, Miles Davis would make two huge innovative impacts with his mid-60’s quintet and the electric stylings of his 1967-1975 period.

The two exceptions on this album are the John Coltrane solos. You can plainly hear the built-up passion and raw energy of American culture through these 4 minutes of improvisational high art. The other solo is on the song “Teo.”

Let’s take a deep dive into John Coltrane’s “sheets of sound” period. This can be considered the tail end of this era. “Bya-Ya” is more bebop-rooted than this solo. The solo on SMPWC has a few bebop moments, which we will detail, but i’d say it’s getting close to the more raw, arpeggio-based improvisation style found on recordings such at Live at the Village Vanguard. If early sheets of sounds seem like an attempt to channel passion via virtuosity, this is passion from a less-tightly structured, more ad-hoc style. This split can be heard as a major theme in contemporary jazz improvisors, compare say the melodic vocabulary of Dave Douglas and Wynton Marsalis, Eric Alexander or Mark Turner.

I consider this solo to be mostly lyrical, and the passion can be plainly heard. The tone quality is his most “metallic,” a difficult to describe quality.

A few recurring melodic themes are as follows:

measures #8-10: ascending Dm scale, Db7 or C7alt, C major arpeggio

m#16-18: a typical bebop lick

m#35-45: a “loco” passage, where the notes are difficult to determine

Download: john-coltrane-solo-on-someday-my-prince-will-come

Advertisements

9 comments

    1. Hi-

      I will check on it. You may want to try a few different browsers to see if you have different results.

      Thanks and sorry for the error and thanks for letting me know. I am super busy but will try and get it looked at.

    1. Hi – It works on my end, what browser are you using? Try another browser to see if that does the trick.

      1. Still not working in any of my browsers. The error is a #403: file requires authorization. You need to be logged in and a member of this blog to view it. What does the member part mean and how can I become one?
        Thanks very much.

      1. Thank you so much for this. You have handled the problem really well.
        Sorry for any inconvenience this might have caused you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s